As we explore the history of McDonough County and the many towns that make up the county, a recent history of churches in Bushnell, prompted updated information about one such church, the First Presbyterian Church.
The Church has served the town's spiritual center for more than 150 years, surviving closures, relocations, and financial challenges since its congregation first organized in 1856. Now, the church’s historic building seeks new ownership—and a new purpose.
The congregation continues to meet at its Community Christian Center, leaving the historic brick structure available for sale. The nearly 7,000-square-foot structure sits in the heart of Bushnell on roughly half an acre. It features a main-floor kitchen and a large basement cafeteria, restrooms on both levels, and potential for seven bedrooms—five upstairs and two on the main floor. The all-brick building is handicap accessible and listed through Key Realtors of Macomb for $125,000.
The church's history reflects the town's own evolution. Founded in 1856, the congregation closed in 1859, then reopened in 1868 and relocated to its current location. Over the decades, members funded significant renovations and improvements that kept the building structurally sound and relevant to community life.
The listing describes the space as offering 'endless opportunities'—a hint at the challenge facing potential buyers. The building is being sold as-is, meaning any restoration or conversion work falls to the new owner.
For now, the brick building waits. Whether it becomes apartments, a community center, an event venue, or something else entirely depends on who walks through its doors next—and what they envision for Bushnell's past.
For more information contact Key Realtors at 309837-6464 or go to https:// keyhomes4sale.com/homesfor- sale
First Presbyterian church facing Hurst St. keyhomes4sale.com
An Inside View - stained glass windows and vaulted ceillings
