The Colchester Public Works Committee wrestled with the future of the city’s water supply during its September 25 meeting, debating a $1.7 million water lift station at Bishop Street and an $8 million Reverse Osmosis Water Plant. The projects also come with ongoing personnel and operational costs projected over 15 to 20 years.
Several aldermen expressed concerns about the hefty price tag, especially since Colchester currently purchases all its water from the City of Macomb under a recently renewed 20-year contract negotiated by former Mayor Eric Haines. Alderman Kim Limkeman, who sits on the Public Works Committee, noted the city’s shrinking population and the financial strain on the water department, which is barely breaking even. She warned that future generations could face higher taxes and water rates to cover the new facilities.
The West Prairie 103 School District, which buys water from Dallas City, could become a potential customer for Colchester’s water, adding to retail sales within Colchester and nearby Tennessee. Alderman Donna Wetzel suggested that owning a reliable, local water source might attract families and businesses to Colchester, rather than relying entirely on Macomb.
Dough Erickson, a professional engineer with Benton Engineering, told the committee that Dallas City’s water supply is nearly maxed out, making West Prairie a promising market. “There’s a lot of rural population sending kids to West Prairie schools,” Erickson said, highlighting potential revenue from tapping into that customer base.
Limkeman added, “There’s revenue opportunity beyond retail sales in Colchester. I’m familiar with operations in Astoria, which has tapped into similar markets.”
Alderman David Frost framed the debate as a choice between Colchester becoming a producer of clean, drinkable water for future generations or continuing to buy water from Macomb. He acknowledged the project’s appeal but said long-term funding plans are fueling tension over whether to build or keep purchasing water.
Public Works Committee Chair Alderman Frances Welch said a decision is imminent. The issue will go to the Committee of the Whole this week before city officials deliberate ahead of a vote at the City Council meeting on Monday, October 6, 2025.
